Pros: The feedback I received from the client was mostly positive, they liked the nighttime poolside image the most out of the three images and also commented on how they like how natural and unposed it was. Which is hopefully a good thing and match well back to my concept of a girls night/Holiday and with their target audience being slightly older and more female leaning I think this could work

Cons: Some things to change were add more sharpen to the bottle and the label so that it more of a main focus in each image, also adding some brightness back as when presenting some of the image could appear a bit darker then on my own screen. Also changing the colour of the bottle back to that lighter blue again maybe as in the night time shoots it is much more of a darker blue. I also myself think that the cinemagraph could use a lot more work with the movement as the glass move to the side and isn't as smooth as I would want it to be for final hand in.

As the client liked my images I didn't want to change too much about them. I just selected the bottle within each image and masked it and upped the contrast to make it stand out better from the background as once again it is the main product and you want to highlight that within the images. I also did any last minute retouching on the bottle so that it once again looks the best it can. I've put the ones I placed in the presentation next to my final images so that I could better see the differences and if I needed to make any other changes. 

For changes to the cinemagraph I decided to restart the whole thing as I think the movement worked well before but it needed a lot of work. I still used the same video but just decided to paint less of the movement into the final moving image so that it wouldn't show as much of the camera shake from the original video. I think that this cinemagraph overall works a lot better.